1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32 | INVESTIGATION REVEALED THE FOLLOWING:
Allegation: A comfortable temperature is not maintained in resident's apartment.
It is alleged that the facility has failed to provide a comfortable temperature in resident #1 (R1’s) apartment. The complainant reports the (R1’s) #205 apartment is either too cold or it is too hot. It is never a comfortable temperature and that (R1) has a problem breathing. The complainant claims the heater is on, it creates a loud noise and produces a foul odor. The Department conducted a visit in (R1’s) apartment and performed a room temperature assessment at 1:03 pm with a wireless digital thermometer. The test revealed the room temperature at 78 degrees F with no air conditioning or heater on. The air conditioning was turned on and the temperature dropped down to 76-77 degrees F and when heating was sampled it brought it back to 78-79 degrees F. The air conditioning and heating system were working properly, and it did not cause a loud noise or disbursed a foul odor when the air or heater was on. An interview with (R1) claims that the maintenance and administrative staff have been made aware of the ongoing problem. but also claims that staff has been responsive to address this issue. (R1) still persists there is a problem even though it has been inspected. An interview with the executive director (S1) and maintenance director (S2) both argue that (R1) has addressed her problems only with the system making loud noises and did not have any knowledge of the temperature or the foul odor. Interviews with residents #2 - #7 (R2-R7) all stated that had no concerns with room temperatures in their apartments. (R2-R7) all reported that management is responsive when it comes to repairs or maintenance services. (S2) states the facility does not have central air or heating and that each apartment has an individual air and heating system. The Department conducted assessments in rooms #201, #203, and #211 and found temperature readings at normal 78 degrees F, and all systems were working properly. A certified ac/heating specialist was contacted by management who performed service in (R1's) apartment on 03/01/22, indicated no prominent issues with the system.
Based on information gathered, an inspection of the facility, observation, analysis records of (R-1)'s service records, interviews, and temperature test conducted, the Department found no evidence to support the allegation "A comfortable temperature is not maintained in resident's apartment."
Although the allegations may have happened or are valid, there is not a preponderance of evidence to prove the alleged violations, did or did not occur, therefore the allegations are Unsubstantiated.
An exit interview with Safoora Ahamed and a copy of the report were provided. |